<link href="https://fonts.googleapis.com/css2?family=Figtree:wght@300;400;500;600;700;800;900&amp;display=swap" rel="stylesheet"> NewsTrüpp joins Skillcloud, expanding HR consulting and outsourced HR servicesRead the announcement
Managed Services & Consulting for HR · Payroll · HRIS · Talent
Compensation

What Should You Offer When Backfilling a Role?

The previous employee’s salary is not the right starting point. What should set the pay range instead, and how to get ahead of the common problems.

Compensation2 min read

When backfilling a position, the previous employee’s salary should not determine the budget or pay range for the role. Instead, the appropriate salary level should reflect current market rates, your compensation philosophy, internal equity, and the skills required for success in the role.

Common challenges employers and recruiters face

  1. The previous employee may have been in the role for a long time, so the salary may not align with current market conditions.
  2. If the employer has not reviewed local market conditions in several years, the market rate for the role may not align with the initial budget.
  3. Candidate salary expectations may not align with the budget if the salary is not included in the job posting.
  4. The role being filled may have evolved to include new responsibilities or to address evolving business needs.

How can employers be proactive?

  1. Reassess the role before posting to confirm responsibilities, skills, and scope.
  2. Benchmark the role against current market data. Use reliable, HR-reported data to understand the median salary and overall market competitiveness.
  3. Know your pay transparency obligations. If you’re in an area with pay transparency requirements, ensure you have a data-driven compensation model and a defined hiring range before recruiting begins.
  4. Be proactive with candidates regarding transparency.
The bottom line

Price the role you are hiring for today, not the one you filled years ago. Market data, your compensation philosophy, internal equity and the skills the role now requires should set the range.

About the authors

Kari Meillat

Kari Meillat is Senior Compensation Manager at Skillcloud HCM Solutions.

Connect with Kari on LinkedIn
Debbie Pearl

Debbie Pearl is Director of Talent Acquisition, RPO at Skillcloud HCM Solutions.

Connect with Debbie on LinkedIn

Backfilling a role soon?

Talk to the team at Skillcloud to see how our Talent Acquisition and Compensation professionals can help.

Talk to an Advisor
Let's Talk

Have a question this article did not answer?

Every hiring plan is different. Tell us your situation and we will give you a straight answer.